diff --git a/manage/updater-ui.js b/manage/updater-ui.js
index 7fb07718..5141969b 100644
--- a/manage/updater-ui.js
+++ b/manage/updater-ui.js
@@ -127,10 +127,6 @@ function reportUpdateState({updated, style, error, STATES}) {
     ['no-update', 0],
     ['update-problem', 0],
   ]);
-  if (typeof error === 'object' && error.message) {
-    // UserCSS meta errors provide an object
-    error = error.message;
-  }
   if (updated) {
     newClasses.set('can-update', true);
     entry.updatedCode = style;
@@ -152,6 +148,9 @@ function reportUpdateState({updated, style, error, STATES}) {
       error = t('updateCheckSkippedLocallyEdited') + '\n' + t('updateCheckManualUpdateHint');
     } else if (error === STATES.MAYBE_EDITED) {
       error = t('updateCheckSkippedMaybeLocallyEdited') + '\n' + t('updateCheckManualUpdateHint');
+    } else if (typeof error === 'object' && error.message) {
+      // UserCSS meta errors provide an object
+      error = error.message;
     }
     const message = same ? t('updateCheckSucceededNoUpdate') : error;
     newClasses.set('no-update', true);