diff --git a/common/notification.ts b/common/notification.ts
index 47c55cc6..affa33cb 100644
--- a/common/notification.ts
+++ b/common/notification.ts
@@ -138,7 +138,7 @@ export const getDestinationsForUser = async (
   privateUser: PrivateUser,
   reason: notification_reason_types | keyof notification_subscription_types
 ) => {
-  const notificationSettings = privateUser.notificationSubscriptionTypes
+  const notificationSettings = privateUser.notificationPreferences
   let destinations
   let subscriptionType: keyof notification_subscription_types | undefined
   if (Object.keys(notificationSettings).includes(reason)) {
@@ -151,9 +151,11 @@ export const getDestinationsForUser = async (
       ? notificationSettings[subscriptionType]
       : []
   }
+  // const unsubscribeEndpoint = getFunctionUrl('unsubscribe')
   return {
     sendToEmail: destinations.includes('email'),
     sendToBrowser: destinations.includes('browser'),
+    // unsubscribeUrl: `${unsubscribeEndpoint}?id=${privateUser.id}&type=${subscriptionType}`,
     urlToManageThisNotification: `${DOMAIN}/notifications?tab=settings&section=${subscriptionType}`,
   }
 }
diff --git a/common/user.ts b/common/user.ts
index 5d427744..7bd89906 100644
--- a/common/user.ts
+++ b/common/user.ts
@@ -65,9 +65,7 @@ export type PrivateUser = {
   initialDeviceToken?: string
   initialIpAddress?: string
   apiKey?: string
-  /** @deprecated - use notificationSubscriptionTypes */
-  notificationPreferences?: notification_subscribe_types
-  notificationSubscriptionTypes: notification_subscription_types
+  notificationPreferences: notification_subscription_types
   twitchInfo?: {
     twitchName: string
     controlToken: string
@@ -142,9 +140,6 @@ export const getDefaultNotificationSettings = (
   privateUser?: PrivateUser,
   noEmails?: boolean
 ) => {
-  const prevPref = privateUser?.notificationPreferences ?? 'all'
-  const wantsLess = prevPref === 'less'
-  const wantsAll = prevPref === 'all'
   const {
     unsubscribedFromCommentEmails,
     unsubscribedFromAnswerEmails,
@@ -161,111 +156,96 @@ export const getDefaultNotificationSettings = (
   return {
     // Watched Markets
     all_comments_on_watched_markets: constructPref(
-      wantsAll,
+      true,
       !unsubscribedFromCommentEmails
     ),
     all_answers_on_watched_markets: constructPref(
-      wantsAll,
+      true,
       !unsubscribedFromAnswerEmails
     ),
 
     // Comments
-    tips_on_your_comments: constructPref(
-      wantsAll || wantsLess,
-      !unsubscribedFromCommentEmails
-    ),
-    comments_by_followed_users_on_watched_markets: constructPref(
-      wantsAll,
-      false
-    ),
+    tips_on_your_comments: constructPref(true, !unsubscribedFromCommentEmails),
+    comments_by_followed_users_on_watched_markets: constructPref(true, false),
     all_replies_to_my_comments_on_watched_markets: constructPref(
-      wantsAll || wantsLess,
+      true,
       !unsubscribedFromCommentEmails
     ),
     all_replies_to_my_answers_on_watched_markets: constructPref(
-      wantsAll || wantsLess,
+      true,
       !unsubscribedFromCommentEmails
     ),
     all_comments_on_contracts_with_shares_in_on_watched_markets: constructPref(
-      wantsAll,
+      true,
       !unsubscribedFromCommentEmails
     ),
 
     // Answers
     answers_by_followed_users_on_watched_markets: constructPref(
-      wantsAll || wantsLess,
+      true,
       !unsubscribedFromAnswerEmails
     ),
     answers_by_market_creator_on_watched_markets: constructPref(
-      wantsAll || wantsLess,
+      true,
       !unsubscribedFromAnswerEmails
     ),
     all_answers_on_contracts_with_shares_in_on_watched_markets: constructPref(
-      wantsAll,
+      true,
       !unsubscribedFromAnswerEmails
     ),
 
     // On users' markets
     your_contract_closed: constructPref(
-      wantsAll || wantsLess,
+      true,
       !unsubscribedFromResolutionEmails
     ), // High priority
     all_comments_on_my_markets: constructPref(
-      wantsAll || wantsLess,
+      true,
       !unsubscribedFromCommentEmails
     ),
     all_answers_on_my_markets: constructPref(
-      wantsAll || wantsLess,
+      true,
       !unsubscribedFromAnswerEmails
     ),
-    subsidized_your_market: constructPref(wantsAll || wantsLess, true),
+    subsidized_your_market: constructPref(true, true),
 
     // Market updates
     resolutions_on_watched_markets: constructPref(
-      wantsAll || wantsLess,
+      true,
       !unsubscribedFromResolutionEmails
     ),
-    market_updates_on_watched_markets: constructPref(
-      wantsAll || wantsLess,
-      false
-    ),
+    market_updates_on_watched_markets: constructPref(true, false),
     market_updates_on_watched_markets_with_shares_in: constructPref(
-      wantsAll || wantsLess,
+      true,
       false
     ),
     resolutions_on_watched_markets_with_shares_in: constructPref(
-      wantsAll || wantsLess,
+      true,
       !unsubscribedFromResolutionEmails
     ),
 
     //Balance Changes
-    loan_income: constructPref(wantsAll || wantsLess, false),
-    betting_streaks: constructPref(wantsAll || wantsLess, false),
-    referral_bonuses: constructPref(wantsAll || wantsLess, true),
-    unique_bettors_on_your_contract: constructPref(
-      wantsAll || wantsLess,
-      false
-    ),
+    loan_income: constructPref(true, false),
+    betting_streaks: constructPref(true, false),
+    referral_bonuses: constructPref(true, true),
+    unique_bettors_on_your_contract: constructPref(true, false),
     tipped_comments_on_watched_markets: constructPref(
-      wantsAll || wantsLess,
+      true,
       !unsubscribedFromCommentEmails
     ),
-    tips_on_your_markets: constructPref(wantsAll || wantsLess, true),
-    limit_order_fills: constructPref(wantsAll || wantsLess, false),
+    tips_on_your_markets: constructPref(true, true),
+    limit_order_fills: constructPref(true, false),
 
     // General
-    tagged_user: constructPref(wantsAll || wantsLess, true),
-    on_new_follow: constructPref(wantsAll || wantsLess, true),
-    contract_from_followed_user: constructPref(wantsAll || wantsLess, true),
+    tagged_user: constructPref(true, true),
+    on_new_follow: constructPref(true, true),
+    contract_from_followed_user: constructPref(true, true),
     trending_markets: constructPref(
       false,
       !unsubscribedFromWeeklyTrendingEmails
     ),
     profit_loss_updates: constructPref(false, true),
-    probability_updates_on_watched_markets: constructPref(
-      wantsAll || wantsLess,
-      false
-    ),
+    probability_updates_on_watched_markets: constructPref(true, false),
     thank_you_for_purchases: constructPref(
       false,
       !unsubscribedFromGenericEmails
diff --git a/firestore.rules b/firestore.rules
index 82392787..6f2ea90a 100644
--- a/firestore.rules
+++ b/firestore.rules
@@ -77,7 +77,7 @@ service cloud.firestore {
       allow read: if userId == request.auth.uid || isAdmin();
       allow update: if (userId == request.auth.uid || isAdmin())
                        && request.resource.data.diff(resource.data).affectedKeys()
-                         .hasOnly(['apiKey', 'unsubscribedFromResolutionEmails', 'unsubscribedFromCommentEmails', 'unsubscribedFromAnswerEmails', 'notificationPreferences', 'unsubscribedFromWeeklyTrendingEmails', 'notificationSubscriptionTypes', 'twitchInfo']);
+                         .hasOnly(['apiKey', 'unsubscribedFromResolutionEmails', 'unsubscribedFromCommentEmails', 'unsubscribedFromAnswerEmails', 'unsubscribedFromWeeklyTrendingEmails', 'notificationPreferences', 'twitchInfo']);
     }
 
     match /private-users/{userId}/views/{viewId} {
diff --git a/functions/src/create-user.ts b/functions/src/create-user.ts
index 71272222..ab5f014a 100644
--- a/functions/src/create-user.ts
+++ b/functions/src/create-user.ts
@@ -83,7 +83,7 @@ export const createuser = newEndpoint(opts, async (req, auth) => {
     email,
     initialIpAddress: req.ip,
     initialDeviceToken: deviceToken,
-    notificationSubscriptionTypes: getDefaultNotificationSettings(auth.uid),
+    notificationPreferences: getDefaultNotificationSettings(auth.uid),
   }
 
   await firestore.collection('private-users').doc(auth.uid).create(privateUser)
diff --git a/functions/src/emails.ts b/functions/src/emails.ts
index e9ef9630..bb9f7195 100644
--- a/functions/src/emails.ts
+++ b/functions/src/emails.ts
@@ -214,7 +214,7 @@ export const sendOneWeekBonusEmail = async (
   if (
     !privateUser ||
     !privateUser.email ||
-    !privateUser.notificationSubscriptionTypes.onboarding_flow.includes('email')
+    !privateUser.notificationPreferences.onboarding_flow.includes('email')
   )
     return
 
@@ -247,7 +247,7 @@ export const sendCreatorGuideEmail = async (
   if (
     !privateUser ||
     !privateUser.email ||
-    !privateUser.notificationSubscriptionTypes.onboarding_flow.includes('email')
+    !privateUser.notificationPreferences.onboarding_flow.includes('email')
   )
     return
 
@@ -279,7 +279,7 @@ export const sendThankYouEmail = async (
   if (
     !privateUser ||
     !privateUser.email ||
-    !privateUser.notificationSubscriptionTypes.thank_you_for_purchases.includes(
+    !privateUser.notificationPreferences.thank_you_for_purchases.includes(
       'email'
     )
   )
@@ -460,9 +460,7 @@ export const sendInterestingMarketsEmail = async (
   if (
     !privateUser ||
     !privateUser.email ||
-    !privateUser.notificationSubscriptionTypes.trending_markets.includes(
-      'email'
-    )
+    !privateUser.notificationPreferences.trending_markets.includes('email')
   )
     return
 
diff --git a/functions/src/scripts/create-new-notification-preferences.ts b/functions/src/scripts/create-new-notification-preferences.ts
index a6bd1a0b..2796f2f7 100644
--- a/functions/src/scripts/create-new-notification-preferences.ts
+++ b/functions/src/scripts/create-new-notification-preferences.ts
@@ -17,7 +17,7 @@ async function main() {
         .collection('private-users')
         .doc(privateUser.id)
         .update({
-          notificationSubscriptionTypes: getDefaultNotificationSettings(
+          notificationPreferences: getDefaultNotificationSettings(
             privateUser.id,
             privateUser,
             disableEmails
diff --git a/functions/src/scripts/create-private-users.ts b/functions/src/scripts/create-private-users.ts
index f9b8c3a1..21e117cf 100644
--- a/functions/src/scripts/create-private-users.ts
+++ b/functions/src/scripts/create-private-users.ts
@@ -21,7 +21,7 @@ async function main() {
       id: user.id,
       email,
       username,
-      notificationSubscriptionTypes: getDefaultNotificationSettings(user.id),
+      notificationPreferences: getDefaultNotificationSettings(user.id),
     }
 
     if (user.totalDeposits === undefined) {
diff --git a/functions/src/scripts/update-notification-preferences.ts b/functions/src/scripts/update-notification-preferences.ts
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..0e2dc243
--- /dev/null
+++ b/functions/src/scripts/update-notification-preferences.ts
@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
+import * as admin from 'firebase-admin'
+
+import { initAdmin } from './script-init'
+import { getPrivateUser } from 'functions/src/utils'
+import { filterDefined } from 'common/lib/util/array'
+import { FieldValue } from 'firebase-admin/firestore'
+initAdmin()
+
+const firestore = admin.firestore()
+
+async function main() {
+  // const privateUsers = await getAllPrivateUsers()
+  const privateUsers = filterDefined([
+    await getPrivateUser('6hHpzvRG0pMq8PNJs7RZj2qlZGn2'),
+  ])
+  await Promise.all(
+    privateUsers.map((privateUser) => {
+      if (!privateUser.id) return Promise.resolve()
+      return firestore.collection('private-users').doc(privateUser.id).update({
+        // eslint-disable-next-line @typescript-eslint/ban-ts-comment
+        // @ts-ignore
+        notificationPreferences: privateUser.notificationSubscriptionTypes,
+        notificationSubscriptionTypes: FieldValue.delete(),
+      })
+    })
+  )
+}
+
+if (require.main === module) main().then(() => process.exit())
diff --git a/web/components/notification-settings.tsx b/web/components/notification-settings.tsx
index 83ebf894..d18896bd 100644
--- a/web/components/notification-settings.tsx
+++ b/web/components/notification-settings.tsx
@@ -183,8 +183,8 @@ export function NotificationSettings(props: {
       toast
         .promise(
           updatePrivateUser(privateUser.id, {
-            notificationSubscriptionTypes: {
-              ...privateUser.notificationSubscriptionTypes,
+            notificationPreferences: {
+              ...privateUser.notificationPreferences,
               [subscriptionTypeKey]: destinations.includes(setting)
                 ? destinations.filter((d) => d !== setting)
                 : uniq([...destinations, setting]),
@@ -240,7 +240,7 @@ export function NotificationSettings(props: {
   const getUsersSavedPreference = (
     key: keyof notification_subscription_types
   ) => {
-    return privateUser.notificationSubscriptionTypes[key] ?? []
+    return privateUser.notificationPreferences[key] ?? []
   }
 
   const Section = memo(function Section(props: {